Cheese Spreads

We offer eight Lancaster cheese spreads: Asiago Artichoke, Cheddar Bacon Horseradish, Garlic & Herb Cream Cheese, Port Wine, Swiss Almond, Vegetable Cream Cheese, White Cheddar Horseradish, and Yellow Cheddar (made with 9-month aged sharp cheddar). All are priced at $6.99 and available online with nationwide shipping.

Cheese spreads pair best with crackers, pretzels, sliced bread, and fresh vegetables. We recommend pairing our Lancaster spreads with Hammond’s Pretzels or Wheat Crackers, which we carry alongside our spreads. For a charcuterie board, options like our Cheddar Bacon Horseradish or Port Wine spread pair beautifully with Lebanon bologna, sweet bologna sticks, and beef jerky.

Port Wine Cheese Spread blends the rich, musky, slightly sweet flavors of port wine with the sharp savoriness of aged cheddar. It’s a classic entertaining spread — popular for holiday gift packs, charcuterie boards, and casual snacking. Ours is available for $6.99 and pairs especially well with wheat crackers and smoked meats.

The best spreads for crackers balance bold flavor with a smooth, spreadable consistency. Our top picks are Cheddar Bacon Horseradish (savory and smoky with a hint of heat), Garlic & Herb Cream Cheese (bright and earthy), and Yellow Cheddar (classic sharp made with 9-month aged cheese). All three are favorites for entertaining and pair especially well with our Hammond’s Pretzels or Wheat Crackers.

Yes, our cheese spreads are a popular addition to Lancaster County gift baskets. They’re available individually or as part of our curated meat and cheese gift packs, like the Best of Lancaster County gift pack. Their compact size, bold flavors, and Lancaster heritage make them a natural fit for food lover gifts, holidays, and corporate orders.